What is the hardest position in baseball? Pitcher, catcher or shortstop?

4.9/5 - (9 votes)

What is the hardest position in baseball?

Catcher: the hardest position in baseball

Catcher is the most unusual position in baseball and the second-most difficult position to play. Since this position is on the receiving end of the pitcher’s pitches, catching involves you in every pitch of the game. He stands in the batter’s box.

When the pitcher tosses the ball, he squats behind home plate and tries to catch it. He defends the area behind home plate. He tries to collect the ball and touch home plate before a runner reaches it after it is in play, much like other fielders, or he tosses the ball to the other bases to get a runner out.

Catcher is the hardest position because of the physical toll it takes on the body. The catcher has many physical challenges and must wear protective equipment.. 

Why catching is the hardest postion in baseball?

High Skilled

The catcher is sometimes referred to as the field’s general for a reason. He has to be always alert to his surroundings. A catcher must be well-versed in the skills and shortcomings of his teammates as well as those of his rivals.

A catcher is more likely to make wise and prompt judgments the more he is aware of what is happening to everyone around him. Whether they are in the starting lineup or not, the catcher needs to have a thorough understanding of every player on the opposing team.


Physically Demanding

The job of catcher is one of the most difficult positions on the field. Some could argue that being the pitcher is almost as difficult.

Even if such were the case, a starting pitcher only works for a few innings every five-day span. Five days a week, a good catcher plays in at least nine innings. Just a few sets of squats are a challenging exercise for the majority of individuals.

Throughout the course of a game, a catcher performs many squats and leaps. To be able to manage it, you must have extraordinary durability and strength.

Mental Focus

A catcher needs to be emotionally and psychologically strong in addition to being physically powerful. No matter what is happening in the game, a great catcher should never become emotionally engaged. It is the catcher’s responsibility to keep the bigger pitcher in mind, maintain his pitcher’s composure, and maintain the umpire’s support.

A catcher needs to know what his pitchers require in addition to maintaining his composure among the umpires. Pitchers are frequently the team’s diva, prone to both physical and psychological breakdowns. A catcher needs to be able to counsel a pitcher and recognise when enough is enough.

Bumps and Bruises

 The catcher will suffer bodily harm. Their body was being hit with dirt pitches and foul balls. On certain days, they must cope with high heat, while on others, they must deal with extreme cold.

The general bruising that takes place over the course of a 7 or 9 inning game is genuine. Additionally, the catcher works arduously to keep the pitcher psychologically engaged in the game by often sitting and standing up.

What is the hardest position in baseball

Other hard positions in baseball

Some other postions that many people consider them as hardest baseball positions, they include: pitcher, shortstop, center field, … Let’s discuss together below.

Pitcher (2nd hardest position in baseball)

This position not only has the most crucial task on the field, which is to strike out hitters and stop runs from scoring, but he also has to cope with the tremendous pressure that comes with being in that position.

In order to succeed, a pitcher needs to have a wide range of pitches in his arsenal and understand when to use each one. This position must also possess good pitch control and be able to direct their pitches where they want them to go.

To ensure that they are at full strength when the chance to pitch again arises, they put their attention on recuperation in between starts and maintain a throwing regimen. Since they touch the ball every time they make a play while throwing the pitch, pitchers differ from other positions in this way.

Additionally, they have to cover bases and support throws made after the ball has been hit.


On a baseball diamond, shortstop is one of the hardest outfield positions to play. The infield position where you have to move the most, to your left, to your right, and occasionally into the outfield for short fly balls, is shortstop.

Due to the high amount of balls that are hit to that part of the field and the shortstop’s involvement in a variety of different plays, the shortstop is engaged in a significant portion of the twenty-seven outs. High end range, a powerful arm, and the capacity to stay focused on the game while positioning other fielders are necessary for the shortstop. When runners are dancing or attempting to steal a base, they have duties in cutoffs and covering bases.

Overall, the shortstop is essential to the team’s success.

Center Field: the hardest outfield postition

The center fielder is responsible for covering the greatest ground of any position in the outfield, similar to the shortstop’s duties on the infield, making this position one of the trickier ones in the game.

You need a cannon for an arm and the ability to react swiftly to play centerfield. When a ball is hit into the gap, centerfielders must assist both the right fielder and the left fielder by handling the play themselves or supporting a teammate.

Third Base

Because balls frequently hit at third base are arriving at the position with a very high exit velocity, third base is known as the hot corner.

You need cat-like reflexes, supple hands, and an arm the size of a rocket launcher to play third. The third baseman needs to make challenging plays on bunts or softly hit balls that get beyond the pitcher’s mound in addition to playing an essential part in preventing extra-base hits along the third base line.

Right Field

The difficulty of right field varies based on the calibre of baseball being played.

However, as talent level rises, rightfield becomes incredibly difficult. First and foremost, the right fielder has to have a very powerful arm—possibly the strongest arm on the field save the pitcher’s.

To make the throw from right to third base, which is frequently a game-saving play, a right fielder requires a strong arm.

The above are some hard positions to play in baseball. On the contrary, if you are looking for an easy position to play, you should read the following article: What is the easiest position in baseball?

What skills you need to become a great catcher?

Getting Squat and Building Strong Legs

A player who wants to be a catcher should practise squatting and holding it for 30 seconds at a time. The position of the catcher sometimes involves crouching.

The catcher starts every pitch in this position and is prepared to slide and block a ball in the dirt or stand up from the squat posture to throw out a base runner.


It is simple to lose concentration and wish to play a different position if you are not fully dedicated to your time and the quest to win as many games as you can.

Due to the foul balls that may strike your arms, hands, or torso when playing catcher, you may not be able to bat for the maximum average attainable at the plate. Being the necessary catcher for your team requires the proper attitude and dedication.



The catcher must foresee game developments and always be one step ahead of the action. The catcher must predict what will happen next and be prepared for any situations when runners are on base if a ball is thrown slightly off line.

Making pitch calls

Pitchers start to throw curve balls and off-speed pitches as a player advances to more advanced levels of baseball in an effort to disrupt the batter’s timing and comfort level.

In order to direct the pitcher to the ideal pitch in each circumstance, the finest catchers are able to either acquire a feel for the game or work off of a scouting report.

Be sensitive to the game

In a game, the catchers serve as the team’s defensive coordinator.

Therefore, it is crucial to understand what each player on the pitch is responsible for. Inform yourself on the advantages and disadvantages of your team. The catcher is a crucial team leader in baseball, thus they must be informed about every position on the field in addition to their own.

 Balls blocked in the dirt

One of the most crucial abilities, maybe. Being able to stop balls in the dirt prevents base runners from moving forward and allowing easy runs to be scored.

A pitcher may throw a breaking ball in the dirt with confidence if they are aware that the catcher can stop almost any pitch. The catcher has to focus on getting his knees on the ground and squaring up regularly in order to improve this ability.

A team’s overall success depends on having the greatest catchers, and blocking balls in the dirt is a crucial talent to master.

Fast Release and Powerful Throws

The catcher’s ability to leap out of his crouch and deliver a powerful, precise throw to second or third base to snag a possible base thief is the last talent for today. The most effective catchers are fast to release and hurl the ball with a short armlike motion. Both good footwork and a powerful arm are necessary.

The catcher’s success will be facilitated by his or her foresight and footwork. The catcher has to practise making a rapid release and throwing to the appropriate base. The qualities of an excellent throwing catcher are accuracy, speed, and throw location.

Be a leader

Being a pitcher, leadership can be the most crucial skill. A catcher can assist as a pitching instructor on the field or during a game. A catcher must enhance the appearance of others around them. They may do this by fostering a positive team environment and ensuring that everyone is contributing their fair share.

If a pitcher becomes agitated about a particular call, catchers must know how to calm them down. Catchers are in the greatest position to take the lead since they have the finest overall field vision.

Some mistakes in selecting a perfect position made by the Players

What is the right position for a youth? Here are some common mistakes made by players and parents in selecting a perfect position to reach the next level.

Mistake – 1: Aspiring to choose a position that is not a good fit for you

Mistake – 2: Become too stiff about that position

Mistake – 3: Playing in too many positions without acquiring the skill

Final Thoughts

Whatever position one chooses to play, it requires skill development and attention to the craft specific to that position. The finest athletes practise their fielding and hitting abilities every day.

All baseball players must maintain their mental toughness, dedication to their sport, and ability to be excellent teammates through adversity. Catchers need to be the team’s leader and be strong both physically and psychologically.

The physical ability must be paired with an extremely strong leadership position and outstanding baseball strategic expertise. The success of the project as a whole depends on being fit and prepared for the challenge of the day. This article clearly answers the question – “What is the hardest position in baseball?”

Read more articles:







Leave a Comment